How to prepare for your first counseling session: what to share when you reach out, how matching works, what happens in session one, and finding the fit.
By William Schroeder, LPC, NCC and clinically reviewed by Teri Schroeder, LCSW
Starting therapy can feel like a big step, and not knowing what comes next makes it harder. The best way to prepare for your first counseling session is to share as much detail as you can when you reach out, and to think about what has and hasn’t helped you before. Here is how the process works at Just Mind, from the moment you contact us to the end of your first session.
Step 1: Reach Out
You can call us or fill out our online form. Either way, we ask what is bringing you in so we can match you with the right therapist.
The more specific you can be, the better your match. “Anxiety” is a start. “Anxiety about driving since a bad car wreck a few months ago” tells us a lot more. The first might look like generalized anxiety. The second may be connected to trauma, and that changes who we would pair you with. In that case, someone trained in EMDR, a therapy built to resolve single-incident traumas, might help you get through it most quickly.
Step 2: Getting Matched
Our client care team of four people reads what you share. They know our therapists, their training and their availability, and they use all of that to find the right person for you.
Sometimes they will tell you, “I know you asked for this therapist, but based on what you shared, we think this other person might be a better fit.” That is on purpose. We want to help you find the right person the first time.
Matching usually takes a day or two, depending on how many people are reaching out at the time. You can hear from us by email, text or phone. If we have a question, answering it or letting us call you back makes things go even faster.
People tell us in their feedback how much they appreciate this personal touch. Our goal is a high-quality match for you, your child or your partner, so you get in with the right person the first time.
Step 3: Paperwork
Once you are matched, you will fill out intake paperwork. All of it goes to your therapist ahead of time, so they come into your first session already knowing a lot about you.
What Happens in Your First Session
Your therapist will have read your paperwork before you arrive. They may have questions about it, or they may not. Every therapist does this a little differently.
Our therapists use a shared intake interview as a guide, but each one asks their own questions, shaped by their training and the way they work. Expect to talk about what brought you in, some background, and what you hope will be different.
How to Prepare
If you have been to therapy before, think about these ahead of time:
- What helped, and what didn’t.
- Any books, tools or resources that helped you make progress.
- What you learned about yourself along the way.
If telling your whole story at once feels overwhelming, you don’t have to. Break it into smaller pieces and start with the parts that feel easier to talk about. You and your therapist can get to the rest over time.
The Biggest Worry: Will This Be the Right Fit?
This is the question most new clients bring in. Therapy takes time, money and energy, so it is a fair one.
Finding a therapist is a little like online dating. Part of it is chemistry. You might find you do better with someone more outgoing, or someone quieter, or someone with a specific background. Often you don’t know until you are in the room.
That chemistry matters. A large review in the journal Psychotherapy looked at 295 studies with more than 30,000 people. The strength of the relationship between client and therapist was consistently linked to how well therapy worked, whatever kind of therapy it was. That held for online therapy too.
Our client care team works hard to get this right up front. They are trained on our therapists’ approaches and know them well, and they stay in close contact with our operations leaders.
How to Tell After a Session or Two
In general, you just know after a couple of sessions. If you don’t feel a connection, don’t trust them yet, or don’t feel like you are making progress, let our client care team know. We will look at another match on our team based on your feedback.
Sometimes it is as simple as personality. A quieter client might do better with a more outgoing therapist who helps draw them out. Other times the therapist notices something new. For example, someone who came in for ADHD may turn out to need trauma work first, and a different therapist might be the better fit for that.
It can come from you or from your therapist. Either way, it happens, and it is OK. With more than 50 therapists on our team, there are a lot of seasoned people we can match you with. Our post on what to do when therapy isn’t a good fit has more on this.
Good to Know Before You Start
- Switching therapists is easy. Let our client care team know you want to try someone else, and they will set it up.
- We give superbills to every client. If you are using out-of-network benefits, you can send them to your insurance company for possible reimbursement. See our rates and insurance page for details.
- You can come in person or meet online. About 30 to 35% of our sessions in a given week are telehealth, which can make it easier to fit therapy around traffic and a busy schedule. Personally, I lean toward in-person sessions because I think both people get more out of being in the room, but what works best varies from person to person. Read more about our online counseling.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I prepare for my first counseling session?
Share as much detail as you can when you reach out, and think about what has and hasn’t helped you in the past. If telling your whole story feels overwhelming, start with the parts that feel easier.
How long does it take to get matched with a therapist at Just Mind?
Matching usually takes a day or two, depending on how many people are reaching out at the time. Our four-person client care team matches you based on what you share.
What happens in the first therapy session?
Your therapist will have read your intake paperwork. Expect to talk about what brought you in, some background and what you hope will be different.
What if my therapist isn’t the right fit?
You usually know after a couple of sessions. If it isn’t the right fit, let our client care team know, and they will match you with someone else on our team of more than 50 therapists.
Can I do therapy online or in person?
Both. You can come in person or meet online. About 30 to 35% of our sessions in a given week are telehealth.
Ready to Start?
Tell us what is going on, and a real person on our client care team will match you with a therapist who fits. You can also browse our counselors first.

Recent Comments