Gambling

Oklahoma Tribes Lose Casino Compact Lawsuit Despite State Supreme Court Ruling


Four powerful Oklahoma tribes have lost a five-year legal battle to overturn gaming compacts negotiated between the state and two rival tribes, despite an earlier state Supreme Court ruling declaring the agreements invalid.

Oklahoma tribal gaming compacts, Kevin Stitt, Oklahoma casino lawsuit, Cherokee Nation, Oklahoma Supreme Court
Oklahoma Gov. Kevin Stitt, above, was at loggerheads with the state’s powerful casino-operating tribes when he negotiated the disputed agreements in 2020. (Image: Brandon Bell/Getty)

US District Judge Timothy J. Kelly dismissed the lawsuit brought by the Cherokee, Chickasaw, Choctaw, and Citizen Potawatomi nations, finding they had failed to demonstrate that the disputed compacts caused them any actual or imminent harm.

Controversial Compacts

The dispute dates back to 2020, when Oklahoma’s Republican governor, Kevin Stitt, negotiated new gaming compacts with the Comanche Nation and Otoe-Missouria Tribe.

At the time, he was locked in a dispute with the state’s other tribal casino operators over how much of their gaming revenue they should share with the state.

The governor wanted to squeeze more payments out of Oklahoma’s numerous tribal casinos. He claimed that the model compact they had signed in 2004 expired on January 1, 2020 and would have to be renegotiated.

The tribes argued that the language of those agreements indicated the compacts were designed to automatically roll over for another 15 years on that date.

Breaking the Law

Stitt claimed the tribes were breaking the law by offering Class III gaming after 2020. In October 2021, a federal judge agreed with the tribes’ interpretation, allowing gaming to continue.

The agreements between the state and the Comanche and Otoe-Missouria offered terms that were significantly different from the existing model compact, including a flat 4.5% revenue-sharing rate for most gaming at existing casinos.

Oddly, this was lower than the rates of up to 10% under the model compact agreement.

But the new compact also contained provisions for sports betting, additional casino games, and up to six new gaming facilities, subject to legal and regulatory approvals.

The US Department of the Interior allowed the agreements to take effect in June 2020 after failing to act within the statutory 45-day review period, a process known as “no-action approval.”

Two months later, however, the Oklahoma Supreme Court ruled that Stitt had exceeded his authority by negotiating agreements authorizing gambling activities, such as sports betting, that were still prohibited under state law.

The court declared the compacts invalid, finding the state could not legally be bound by them without legislative authorization.

The four plaintiff tribes subsequently challenged the federal approvals, arguing that the agreements gave their competitors unfair advantages.

No Evidence of Harm

Judge Kelly rejected those arguments, finding that the plaintiffs had failed to establish legal standing to pursue their claims.

The Comanche and Otoe-Missouria tribes already operated casinos before the disputed agreements took effect, meaning their continued presence in the market did not constitute increased competition, he reasoned.

Meanwhile, the additional games contemplated by the agreements, including sports betting, remained unauthorized under Oklahoma law and so were not being offered.

Plans for six additional casinos were similarly speculative because the necessary federal land-approval processes had not begun.

The plaintiffs also argued that reduced revenue-sharing payments would allow their rivals to offer larger jackpots and better amenities, but the judge found no evidence supporting that prediction.

Kelly noted that tribal gaming revenues also fund government operations and services rather than necessarily being reinvested in casinos.

His dismissal does not resolve the question of the compacts’ federal legality, nor change the Oklahoma Supreme Court’s ruling they were invalid under state law.

In Philip Conneller’s eight years with Casino.org, he has covered the gaming industry from Las Vegas to Macau and everything in between. He currently focuses his coverage on gaming law, white-collar crime, global money laundering, tribal gaming, politics, and regulation.

Philip was the original features editor for poker’s Bluff Magazine and editor for Bluff Europe, which he helped launch. His writing has also been featured in ESPN, Forbes, Time Out, The Sun, and The Daily Star, as well as iGaming Business, eGaming Review, and numerous other industry news and tech websites.

His news stories for Casino.org/news have been linked by The Washington Post, The Daily Mail, People Magazine, and Jimmy Fallon’s Tonight Show, among many others.

Philip once won $20,000 with 7-2 off-suit. He has been reprimanded for unwittingly playing Elton John’s piano on two separate occasions on both sides of the Atlantic.

He became a writer because he is a lousy pianist.

Philip lives outside London with his wife and children, where he spends his time agonizing about Arsenal FC.

Contact Philip at philip.conneller@casino.org.



Source link

Rambamwellness.com

Leave a Reply